- The Reservation Next Door
- Trouble in Tovaangar
- Too High a Cost, Perhaps Too Bright a Spotlight
- Reading Between the Battle Lines of Land Acknowledgements
- Amid Threats, Kizh Conservancy Selected to Protect Ancient Jurupa Oak
As the last ice age ended 13,000 years ago, the Jurupa Oak in Riverside County managed to survive by adapting to strong northerly winds, drought and fire by cloning itself. This miracle of natural selection is still alive today, outlasting the giant ground sloths, dire wolves and sabre-toothed cats that once roamed Southern California.
Among a variety of other species, two types of mammals thrived alongside the Jurupa, or Hurunga, Oak as the Pleistocene drew to a close; coyotes and indigenous humans.
On Friday, the Gabrieleno Band of Mission Indians – Kizh Nation, lineal descendants of those indigenous peoples, signed a conservancy agreement with housing developer Richland Communities. The agreement appoints the tribe perpetual steward of 510.8 acres of their sacred lands, including the only stand of Jurupa Oak on the planet.
The accord concludes one of the largest “land back” negotiations in California history, and follows the return of 2,800 acres in Siskiyou County to the Shasta Indian Nation in June.
The agreement marks a watershed moment for the Kizh tribe. But the public nature of the planning process by the City of Jurupa Valley exposed, in the words of the tribe’s legal counsel Kara Grant, “years and years of opportunism” by Neo-indigenous Tongva “factions and splinter groups using countless name variations” to make land back claims for their economic ventures.
It is likely that it was one of those factions that sent a ransom note (pictured here) to the Kizh Nation.
Being unclear about the need for anonymity, though, the sender included a return address in Corona on the envelope. Local police were contacted by the Kizh and detectives began an investigation regarding the threat.
To date, no arrests have been made.
Two splinter groups purporting to represent local indigenous tribal members went public expressing their displeasure with the conservancy agreement in no uncertain terms.
A spokesperson for the Shiishongna Tongva Nation – Corona Band Of Gabrielino Indians insisted during a public comment session in Jurupa Valley that the tribe was unlawfully left out of the developer’s planning process and demanded to be consulted about anything having to do with the acreage.
The Kizh Nation countered that the Shiishongna Tongva Nation was not a tribe recognized as such by either the federal government or the State of California.
Another group displeased with the Kizh conservancy agreement has considerably more extensive political connections into Los Angeles County government; the San Gabriel Band of Mission Indians, Gabrieleno-Tongva Nation fronted by Tribal Chairman Anthony Morales. Local News Pasadena previously uncovered the Morales family’s attempt to acquire the Henninger Flats campground from Los Angeles County through the Tongva Taraxat Paxaavxa Conservancy.
Last week, Anthony Morales wrote to Jurupa Valley officials questioning the legitimacy of the Kizh Nation as “a small group that surfaced around 2008,” overlooking archaeological and genealogical records that prove the Kizh (or Quiichi) tribe dates back millennia in the Los Angeles Basin. Morales said he wanted to “ensure that the Jurupa Oak, along with the integrity of the Gabrieleno/Tongva community is protected.”
Morales requested that city officials follow-up with “Mona Recalde,” a Native Community Elected Commissioner on the Los Angeles City/County Native American Indian Commission. Mona Morales Recalde happens to be Anthony Morales’ cousin, and the Commission has no jurisdiction in Riverside County.
Kara Grant, the Kizh Nation’s legal counsel, filed her own letter with the City Council in response to Morales, stating: “The Kizh Nation’s claim to their ancestral lands and status as a tribal government predates the more recent organizations using the name ‘Tongva.’ Claims that the Kizh Nation does not represent the Gabrieleno people not only are inaccurate but intended to confuse and mislead. The Kizh Nation’s history as an indigenous community is well-established and long recognized.”
But that’s all water under the canoe now for the Kizh, who are taking a longer view.
“This conservancy agreement emphasizes the deep, historical connection between the oak tree, the location, and the descendants of those who lived there before,” said Kizh Nation Chief Andrew Salas.
“It suggests that the longevity of the oak tree and the significance of the site are tied to the presence and legacy of the grandchildren of the ancestors who fought for survival over many decades. The tree and the land stand as symbols of endurance and continuity, representing the perseverance of the ancestors and the ongoing presence of their descendants.”
“The sacred oak tree and the tribal resources on this site stand as living proof of the longevity and resilience of my people — the very people who have stewarded these lands on behalf of the Great Creator,” said Salas.
“The reason the site and the oak have endured for thousands of years is to wait and welcome their Indigenous grandchildren, so that we may continue to preserve this land and carry forward the legacy of our ancestors.”
The ignorance and lack of credibility really shows of those groups crying they were denied full considerations. The gabrielino-shoshone group has NO clue as to the consultation process. For ANY considerations for consultation, it is mandated a Tribe MUST be on the Native American Heritage Commission contact list pursuant to AB52. The developer, project managers, government entities are under NO obligation to consult with these “johnny-come-lately” groups. In fact, there is No historical, ethnographic, or genealogical data on the G-S tribal group. Google them, and you will only find a Facebook site, giving no validity as an ancestral tribe.
The Kizh were in consultation on this project since 2017. It is at the discretion of the developer (AB52) who they choose to consult with regarding the project. Morales? Thank the Creator he was not involved. He nearly allowed the desecration of 200 Ancestral graves outside the SG mission. He’s going to complain to the LA County/City Native Commission. Dah! This project was Outside LACO. This Commission has NO jurisdiction of a project not in LACO. Ridiculous!
Congratulations to the Kizh. It has been a battle contending with all these splinter groups that have No documented Lineage to the area. What a tribute to the late Chief Ernie Salas who is still leading his people from above. AHO
The Shiishongna group was named in the article. Not the Gabrielino shoshone.
Great article Mr. Phil Hopkins ,thank you kindly sir in behalf of our Kizh Gabrieleno tribe.
As a tribe we are estatic , honored and what Mr. Pedroza is stating is fact.
We are now stewards of this land and will now have land back to be able to celebrate and continue our legacy with pride and lots of ceremonies..
Words alone cannot express our heartfelt gratitude!!
The article is amazing well written and we thank you for your expertise
Best always Mr. Hopkins and May Creatir God bless you and yours always. AHO!!!!
As Chief Ernie impressed upon the Tribal Members “We must speak for the animals and the plants as they can not speak for themselves.”
Is Phil Hopkins on the Kizh’s payroll or something?
Also that is the fakest ransom letter I have ever seen. What in the Scooby Doo nonsense is that?
The Kizh are bullies. Plain and simple.
Pretty pathetic ransom note, right? With a return address sticker on the envelope. I mean, who does that?
To answer your question, no. I’m not on anyone’s payroll. But I do occasionally win awards for my reporting.